Which one have better performance nowadays?

So I have dusk. Last year batch and it's almost empty rn. Which one should I get between these 3? I try sniffin detour and its like syntetic menthol on the opening. I never try it until drydown. I never had my hand on royal paragon. My dusk is performing really well but people said 2024 batch have very very weak performance so that got me thinking twice to restock dusk again. Any recommendation?